There has been no shortage of finger-pointing following the mess that resulted in a high number of confused and suspicious Mississippi voters having to cast affidavit ballots during the Nov. 3 election that produced Scott Colom’s stunning and historical victory in a race for the U.S. Senate.
Many have put the blame on Michael Watson. In his quest to clean up Mississippi’s notoriously bloated voter rolls, the secretary of state decided he could help county election officials to better identify voters who had moved by using a database provided by Experian, one of the nation’s major credit reporting agencies. Problem was the database, by Experian’s own admission, was unreliable for verifying voter addresses, despite a recommendation from federal officials to the contrary. Watson himself was warned that Experian’s accuracy on addresses might be an issue during a one-county test in 2024 and even more strongly following the March primaries this year. But rather than sounding an alarm, he allowed the 82 counties to proceed as if Experian’s information was reliable, even while he was lining up a different commercial vendor.
Watson, for his part, says the fault lies not with him but with the county election officials for not being careful to verify residency before changing a voter’s status to inactive and triggering the necessity for an affidavit ballot. The secretary of state doesn’t maintain voter rolls. That’s a local responsibility. The secretary of state only provides tools to do the job — in this case, about 113,000 names whose residence on the poll books did not match the address shown for them by Experian or the U.S. Postal Service. It was up to county officials to investigate the discrepancy and decide what action to take.
Watson also claims the uproar on Election Day and in the days afterward was overblown, the result of a suspenseful Senate contest that ousted an incumbent and elected the first Black candidate to a statewide office in Mississippi since Reconstruction. With the eyes of the nation on the vote counting, any glitch was bound to be magnified. In a column he distributed Monday, Watson suggests that the total number of affidavits — 21,484 this year compared to 21,321 in 2024 — “reflects a normal, high-engagement election, not a breakdown in the system.”
Not necessarily. We don’t know from Watson’s numbers, whether for 2026 or 2024, how many voters had to cast affidavit ballots because of an address mix-up or for other reasons, such as not being able to produce a photo ID. In addition, since the turnout in 2026 was 20% less than in 2024, a presidential election year, one would expect the affidavit totals to also be significantly less, not the same.
Finger-pointing aside, how Mississippi deals with the situation when a voter’s address is flagged as potentially inaccurate could be improved.
State law requires local election officials to move voters to inactive status at the same time as they mail notices asking voters to verify their address. Since many counties sent these notices only to the address sourced from Experian’s data, the voters probably never got the notice in those instances where Experian’s information was wrong.
This is an easy fix. The law should be changed to require the notice be sent to both the address on the county’s poll books and the one produced by the secretary of state’s research. And the voter should be marked as inactive only after failing to respond to either notice.
A duplicate mailing would cost a bit more, but it would be worth it. Cutting corners is not the way to deal with something as sensitive as voting rights.