This recent headline on The Washington Post website could not be ignored: “Why the South has such low credit scores.”
The initial suspect seemed obvious. Average income in many Southern states tends to be lower than in the rest of the country, making it less likely for borrowers to repay.
Surprisingly, it’s more than that. Although, if you look at a map of average credit scores in each county in America that accompanies the story, the vast majority of counties in Southern states, stretching from Texas to Virginia, are in one of three blue colors that signify low scores. This includes all 82 Mississippi counties.
The Post suspected race and poverty rates were in play here. But neither was the deciding factor.
“The Blackest parts of the South had roughly the same credit scores as the least-Black areas,” reporter Andrew Van Dam wrote. “And their scores were far lower than places with similar Black populations outside the South.”
As for poverty, he added, “Even some of the South’s biggest, most dynamic cities — think Atlanta or Dallas — have the same below-average credit scores as their more rural Southern neighbors. Within every income bracket, the typical Southerner has a lower credit score than someone who lives in the Northeast, Midwest or West.”
An economist at the Urban Institute, a Washington think tank, quickly diagnosed the South’s biggest problem with debt: medical bills.
Another map of the country, for the percentage of residents being contacted for overdue medical payments, had a similar color split as the credit score map did. Gold counties had less than 14% of their population being asked for a medical payment; blue counties had more than 14% owing money. Once again, many Southern counties were blue.
The next obvious question is why do Southerners owe more money for medical care?
First, we’re the most unhealthy region of the country. As the Post noted, “Poor health tends to go hand in hand with people having overdue medical debt and poor credit scores.”
But that’s not the big issue. The South’s larger problem with medical debt is — no surprise — the decision by eight Southern states not to expand Medicaid through the Affordable Care Act.
“In states that immediately expanded Medicaid (in 2014), medical debt was slashed nearly in half between 2013 and 2020,” the story said. “In states that didn’t expand Medicaid, medical debt fell just 10 percent. ... And in low-income communities in those states, debt levels actually rose.”
The political reasons for not expanding Medicaid in states like Mississippi are understandable, though shortsighted. The information in this story says people without health care coverage, public or private, are paying for this political strategy through higher debt and higher borrowing costs.
Basically, they must hope they don’t get seriously ill. That’s a risky way to live.
— From The (McComb) Enterprise-Journal